مرکزی مواد پر جائیں

سروس

مسئلے کی اطلاع دیں

یہ صفحہ کسی ایک اسٹاپ، روٹ، اسٹیشن یا گاڑی کے بارے میں نہیں ہے۔ کوئی ایک کھولیں تاکہ سگنلمنٹ میں اس کا نام آ جائے، یا مکمل رپورٹ استعمال کریں۔

کیا ہوا
مکمل رپورٹ اکاؤنٹ کی ضرورت نہیں

Orléans East-Cumberland

Bob Bell

جواب دیا گیاکوئی وقت شمار نہیں ہوا

خط و کتابت

شائع شدہ پیغامات اور روکے گئے جوابات کے نوٹس اسی ترتیب میں ہیں جس میں بھیجے یا موصول ہوئے۔ ہر دستاویز اپنی پہلی اشاعت کی تاریخ الگ دکھاتی ہے۔

  1. ہماری بھیجی ہوئی ای میل

    Otranspo · بھیجا گیا یا موصول ہوا · پہلی بار شائع ہوا

    Your ward's transit scorecard, and the $700K contract council never voted on

    Dear Bob Bell,

    I'm an Ottawa resident, a transit rider, and the builder of otranspo.ca, an independent transit platform made in Ottawa. Before anything else, here is the live transit scorecard for Orléans East-Cumberland: https://otranspo.ca/en/city/wards/1. Right now it shows 82.0% of arrivals landing within five minutes of schedule, graded route by route from OC Transpo's own settled arrivals over the last fourteen days, next to a live map of the vehicles running through the ward and a plain list of what would fix the worst of it. Use it at the doors and in debates, no strings attached.

    Here is why I'm writing. Since 2023, the City has committed close to $700,000 to the Montreal company that makes the Transit app, all on one contract (33523-92002-G01). $282,000 for monitoring the real-time data, $180,000 to roll out the free Royale subscription, and another $233,794 in 2025 for rider surveys inside the app. There was no RFP, it was all sole-sourced under an exception in the Procurement By-law, and it never went to council for a vote, staff signed it under delegated authority. It's all in the City's own contract disclosures:

    https://documents.ottawa.ca/sites/default/files/Document%201%20%E2%80%93%20Transit%20Contracts%20awarded%20under%20delegated%20authority%20for%20the%20per_AODA.pdf

    https://documents.ottawa.ca/sites/default/files/Contracts%20Under%20Delegation%20of%20Authority%20January%201%20to%20June%2030%202025-AODA.pdf

    The disclosures also leave basic questions unanswered. Royale is a subscription product, so is the $180,000 a one-time cost or an annual one, and is it priced per rider or a flat fee? At Transit's advertised price of $24.99 a year, $180,000 only covers about 7,200 subscriptions in a city of a million people, and nobody can say what we actually bought because the term and pricing were never made public. The 2025 payment also means the City is paying a Montreal company to compile crowdsourced feedback from Ottawa's own riders.

    Across the river, the STO gets the same app for free. When Gatineau launched real-time tracking in Transit in 2019, the STO's president said publicly that the partnership cost nothing, because showing an agency's buses is Transit's free tier (Le Droit, Jan. 31, 2019: https://ledroit.com/actualites/gatineau/sto-les-parcours-en-temps-reel-6ec8c8b15a3398d70012e209c2fcc63e). What Ottawa paid for is the extras, monitoring the quality of the City's own data feed, sponsoring a premium subscription, and buying crowdsourced rider surveys.

    Riders already get those extras free on otranspo.ca, with independent scorecards for every ward, route and station, crowdsourced rider reports at https://otranspo.ca/en/report where riders log the no-show buses, crowding and breakdowns the official feed never records, and live tracking with real-time traffic. There is nothing to subscribe to, and it costs the City nothing.

    Ottawa already has the bones of a world class system. What we've lost is trust, and residents need to see the system working, not just be told that it works.

    So I'm asking you to commit to three things if you're elected:

    1. A public review at Transit Commission of the sole-source Transit app contract, including its full cost, term, pricing structure, and performance, before it gets extended again.

    2. Fair, open, competitive processes for rider-facing transit technology going forward.

    3. An open partnership framework so qualified Ottawa-built platforms, mine included, can integrate with OC Transpo and share crowdsourced data back with the City.

    I'm publishing every candidate's answer on otranspo.ca before advance voting starts October 1, yes, no, or silence. I'd also welcome 15 minutes to show you or your team the platform.

    Respectfully, Wyatt Baldwin otranspo.ca

    براہ کرم اس ریکارڈ کی جانچ کریں

    اشاعت کی کیفیت: جوں کا توں شائع کیا گیا

    محفوظ شدہ ماخذ اندراج کے ہیش سے میل کھاتا ہے۔

    چیک سم (SHA-256) 4c287c7fe51dac72fd55cc76920d9480e55fb7cf504c450d2bf719b82b70003e

    اس پیغام کا لنک

  2. جواب کا ای میل

    ان کا لکھا ہوا · بھیجا گیا یا موصول ہوا · پہلی بار شائع ہوا

    Re: Your ward's transit scorecard, and the $700K contract council never voted on

    Hi Wyatt, I would love the opportunity to walkthrough the platform and learn more about how it works. In answer to your questions: 1 - I would support a public review of this and all sole-source contracts 2 - I would support a competitive process for any rider-facing solutions 3 - I would support allowing integration for approved third parties. Government data should be open to the extent possible, and I think this suggestion connects to that principle. Thanks, Bob Bell Candidate for Ward 1 Orléans East Cumberland City Councillor bob4orleans@gmail.com On Wed, Sep 9, 2026, 9:36 p.m. Wyatt Baldwin · otranspo.ca < hello@otranspo.ca> wrote: > Dear Bob Bell, > > I'm an Ottawa resident, a transit rider, and the builder of otranspo.ca, > an independent transit platform made in Ottawa. Before anything else, here > is the live transit scorecard for Orléans East-Cumberland: > otranspo.ca/en/city/wards/1. Right now it shows 82.0% of arrivals landing > within five minutes of schedule, graded route by route from OC Transpo's > own settled arrivals over the last fourteen days, next to a live map of the > vehicles running through the ward and a plain list of what would fix the > worst of it. Use it at the doors and in debates, no strings attached. > > Here is why I'm writing. Since 2023, the City has committed close to > $700,000 to the Montreal company that makes the Transit app, all on one > contract (33523-92002-G01). $282,000 for monitoring the real-time data, > $180,000 to roll out the free Royale subscription, and another $233,794 in > 2025 for rider surveys inside the app. There was no RFP, it was all > sole-sourced under an exception in the Procurement By-law, and it never > went to council for a vote, staff signed it under delegated authority. It's > all in the City's own contract disclosures: > > Transit contracts awarded under delegated authority (PDF) > <https://documents.ottawa.ca/sites/default/files/Document%201%20%E2%80%93%20Transit%20Contracts%20awarded%20under%20delegated%20authority%20for%20the%20per_AODA.pdf> > > Contracts under delegation of authority, January 1 to June 30, 2025 (PDF) > <https://documents.ottawa.ca/sites/default/files/Contracts%20Under%20Delegation%20of%20Authority%20January%201%20to%20June%2030%202025-AODA.pdf> > > The disclosures also leave basic questions unanswered. Royale is a > subscription product, so is the $180,000 a one-time cost or an annual one, > and is it priced per rider or a flat fee? At Transit's advertised price of > $24.99 a year, $180,000 only covers about 7,200 subscriptions in a city of > a million people, and nobody can say what we actually bought because the > term and pricing were never made public. The 2025 payment also means the > City is paying a Montreal company to compile crowdsourced feedback from > Ottawa's own riders. > > Across the river, the STO gets the same app for free. When Gatineau > launched real-time tracking in Transit in 2019, the STO's president said > publicly that the partnership cost nothing, because showing an agency's > buses is Transit's free tier (Le Droit, Jan. 31, 2019: Le Droit report > <https://ledroit.com/actualites/gatineau/sto-les-parcours-en-temps-reel-6ec8c8b15a3398d70012e209c2fcc63e>). > What Ottawa paid for is the extras, monitoring the quality of the City's > own data feed, sponsoring a premium subscription, and buying crowdsourced > rider surveys. > > Riders already get those extras free on otranspo.ca, with independent > scorecards for every ward, route and station, crowdsourced rider reports at > otranspo.ca/en/report where riders log the no-show buses, crowding and > breakdowns the official feed never records, and live tracking with > real-time traffic. There is nothing to subscribe to, and it costs the City > nothing. > > Ottawa already has the bones of a world class system. What we've lost is > trust, and residents need to see the system working, not just be told that > it works. > > So I'm asking you to commit to three things if you're elected: > > 1. A public review at Transit Commission of the sole-source Transit app > contract, including its full cost, term, pricing structure, and > performance, before it gets extended again. > > 2. Fair, open, competitive processes for rider-facing transit technology > going forward. > > 3. An open partnership framework so qualified Ottawa-built platforms, mine > included, can integrate with OC Transpo and share crowdsourced data back > with the City. > > I'm publishing every candidate's answer on otranspo.ca before advance > voting starts October 1, yes, no, or silence. I'd also welcome 15 minutes > to show you or your team the platform. > > Respectfully, > Wyatt Baldwin > otranspo.ca >

    براہ کرم اس ریکارڈ کی جانچ کریں

    اشاعت کی کیفیت: جوں کا توں شائع کیا گیا

    محفوظ شدہ ماخذ اندراج کے ہیش سے میل کھاتا ہے۔

    چیک سم (SHA-256) 8ec792a8f61e6f0c537a600e3ea80135dda0a7088cb0f4823e65b79cbc3b319a

    اس پیغام کا لنک

  3. ہماری بھیجی ہوئی ای میل

    Otranspo · بھیجا گیا یا موصول ہوا · پہلی بار شائع ہوا

    A correction to my September 9 letter, and the 15 minutes I offered

    Dear Bob Bell,

    Thank you for replying on September 12. Two things since, and one of them is a correction I owe you.

    My letter put the City's commitments on the Transit app contract (33523-92002-G01) at close to $700,000. The correct figure is $1,157,794. I left out a fourth line because I wasn't certain of the amount: a $462,000 extension in the City's July to December 2024 disclosure, for the app plus customer surveys, data-quality analysis and performance benchmarking. Jenna Jessop, a candidate in Orléans West-Innes, read the disclosures herself and asked me about it. She was right, and I'm grateful she raised it. The corrected total, all four source lines and the revision record are on the contract page: https://otranspo.ca/en/insights/transit-app-contract

    You asked for a walkthrough of the platform, and I haven't booked it. I'm not going to squeeze it into the last four weeks of your campaign; advance voting is about to start and your time belongs to voters right now. After election day on October 26 the offer stands, elected or not, and I'll write to you then to find a time.

    As my letter said, every candidate's answer is published at https://otranspo.ca/en/public-record/candidates-2026 on Thursday, October 1, the day advance voting starts, with my letter beside it. Yours is on file. If you'd rather your position were summarised than quoted, tell me by Wednesday, September 30 and I'll publish it without your words and note that you asked.

    Respectfully, Wyatt Baldwin otranspo.ca

    براہ کرم اس ریکارڈ کی جانچ کریں

    اشاعت کی کیفیت: جوں کا توں شائع کیا گیا

    محفوظ شدہ ماخذ اندراج کے ہیش سے میل کھاتا ہے۔

    چیک سم (SHA-256) 0b8b1966b0c3b65b147ab8f9fdc02e34af4363ad6cc6732f936729f4c948198c

    اس پیغام کا لنک

ترسیل اور جواب کی ٹائم لائن

ڈاک کی ترسیل کی حالت
بھیج دیا گیا؛ موصولی کی تصدیق نہیں ہوئی
درج کی گئی حالت
9 ستمبر، 2026 کو 9:36 PM GMT -4
  1. بھیج دیا گیا؛ موصولی کی تصدیق نہیں ہوئی
  2. ہماری بھیجی ہوئی ای میل · Otranspo
  3. جواب کا ای میل · ان کا لکھا ہوا
  4. بھیج دیا گیا؛ موصولی کی تصدیق نہیں ہوئی
  5. ہماری بھیجی ہوئی ای میل · Otranspo

وہ تین باتیں جو ہم نے مانگیں

نیچے دی گئی تشریح ہماری اپنی ہے، اقتباس نہیں ہے۔ ان کے اپنے الفاظ اس سے نیچے ہیں۔ آپ خود فیصلہ کر سکتے ہیں۔

1 معاہدے کا جائزہ
پابندWould support a public review of this and all sole-source contracts.
2 کھلی خریداری
پابندWould support a competitive process for any rider-facing solution.
3 انٹیگریشن کھولیں
پابندWould support allowing integration for approved third parties, on the principle that government data should be open to the extent possible.

اس صفحے میں تبدیلیاں

  • 28 ستمبر، 2026Publication decision recorded 28 September 2026: the reply is published verbatim, released together with every other reply on 1 October 2026 at 07:00 Ottawa, the day advance voting starts, as the letter of 9 September said.اشاعت کی حالت بدل گئی: ادارتی جائزہ زیر التوا to جوں کا توں شائع کیا گیامتاثرہ پیغام

اگر آپ کا اندراج یہاں ہے

ہر اندراج کھلا رہتا ہے۔ جو جواب مہینوں بعد آئے، وہ بھی شائع کیا جاتا ہے اور صفحہ بتاتا ہے کہ وہ اشاعت کے بعد آیا، دونوں تاریخوں کے ساتھ۔ اگر یہاں کچھ غلط ہو تو براہ کرم ہمیں لکھیں۔ درستی شائع کی جائے گی اور بتایا جائے گا کہ کیا بدلا اور کب۔ اگر آپ نے جواب دیا تھا اور نہیں چاہتے کہ آپ کے الفاظ چھپیں، تو ہمیں بتائیں۔ ہم آپ کا موقف آپ کے الفاظ کے بغیر شائع کریں گے اور یہ بھی درج کریں گے کہ آپ نے یہ درخواست کی۔

ہمیں لکھیں